Study finds paramedic care delivered on-scene for 10 to 35 minutes leads to better outcomes for paediatric cardiac arrests
TORONTO – Less than 10 per cent of paediatric patients who suffer a cardiac arrest outside of the hospital survive. There are many factors which can influence survival rates; paramedic care is one of them.
Thanks to the advanced training of paramedics, today, they can spend more time on the scene doing CPR or providing medical care including administering intravenous fluids and medications. However until now, it has not been known if the length of time spent on the scene and onsite medical interventions by paramedics are associated with improved survival for paediatric patients.
In the largest paediatric cardiac arrest study to date, a team of researchers led by The Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids) and Lawson Health Research Institute found that survival was the highest, especially among teens, with 10 to 35 minutes on the scene in the care and under the treatment of paramedics. The study also found that improved survival was associated with intravenous access and fluid administration, whereas advanced airway attempts (endotracheal intubation) and resuscitation drugs were not. The study is published in Resuscitation.
“Our initial hypothesis was that more time spent on the scene doing quality CPR with advanced medical interventions would mean better patient outcomes. We found that there is an optimal time between 10 and 35 minutes, and after 35 minutes, the outcomes do not improve and actually get worse,” says Dr. Jamie Hutchison, senior author on the study, Staff Physician and Research Director in Critical Care Medicine at SickKids. “Interestingly, we found that while longer on-scene time (more than 35 minutes) was associated with higher rates of resuscitation, it had lower rates of survival [compared to 10 to 35 minutes on the scene]. This paradox is valuable information for paramedics as they weigh the potential benefits of spending more time on the scene while considering how to achieve the best possible outcome for the patient.”
This was an observational study looking at data from the Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium (ROC) cardiac arrest database from 11 North American regions, including Vancouver, Hamilton, Toronto and Ottawa between 2005 and 2012. The team studied 2,244 patients ranging from three days old to 19 years old with non-traumatic out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, and evaluated survival to the time of hospital discharge.
“Our findings show that scene time is significantly associated with survival to hospital discharge, and that only some interventions are associated with survival,” says Dr. Janice Tijssen, principal author on the study, Researcher at Lawson and Paediatric Intensivist at Children's Hospital, London Health Sciences Centre. “For example, placement of intravenous or interosseous needles was associated with improved survival, likely because it allowed fluid administration that was also associated with better outcomes. We hope the findings will help inform paramedics as they make decisions on the best way to treat patients.”
Adolescents had the highest rate of survival followed by children and then infants. Infants had the shortest scene time, fewest interventions and lowest rate of witnessed events (meaning the cause of the arrest was unknown). It is possible that there may be a large number of infants who had sudden infant death syndrome.
The study also revealed that more than 10 minutes on the scene was associated with more interventions, suggesting that a ‘scoop and run’ approach of less than 10 minutes does not allow enough time to apply interventions like IV fluids that may benefit the patient. “But the good news is that in the majority of patients (68.7 per cent) had a scene time between 10 and 35 minutes,” adds Tijssen.
Toronto Paramedic Services, Deputy Chief of Program Development and Service Quality, Cindy Nicholson says, "The findings of this study as well as those of other recent research confirms that early intervention and care from Paramedics in the prehospital setting makes a significant difference in quality of life and outcomes for our patients. This study's findings are not only exciting for Toronto Paramedic Services but for the profession in general and most importantly for the patients in our community who benefit from our evidence-based care."
- 2,244 patients studied (1017 infants, 594 children, 633 teens)
- Infants had the lowest average rate of survival over the whole study period (3.7 per cent) compared to children (9.8 per cent) and teens (16.3 per cent)
- Survival was highest in the 10-35 minutes on scene time group (10.2 per cent) compared to the over 35 minute group (6.9 per cent) and the under 10 minute group (5.3 per cent)
The ROC is funded by the National Institutes of Health - National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute and the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) - Institute of Circulatory and Respiratory Health, the U.S. Army Medical Research & Material Command, Defence Research and Development Canada, the Heart, Stroke Foundation of Canada, the American Heart Association and SickKids Foundation.
This paper is an example of how SickKids, London Health Sciences Centre, St. Michael’s Hospital, The Ottawa Hospital and Children’s Hospital of Eastern Ontario, and Emergency Medical Services in Ontario are contributing to making Ontario Healthier, Wealthier and Smarter www.healthierwealthiersmarter.ca.
About The Hospital for Sick Children
The Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids) is recognized as one of the world’s foremost paediatric health-care institutions and is Canada’s leading centre dedicated to advancing children’s health through the integration of patient care, research and education. Founded in 1875 and affiliated with the University of Toronto, SickKids is one of Canada’s most research-intensive hospitals and has generated discoveries that have helped children globally. Its mission is to provide the best in complex and specialized family-centred care; pioneer scientific and clinical advancements; share expertise; foster an academic environment that nurtures health-care professionals; and champion an accessible, comprehensive and sustainable child health system. SickKids is proud of its vision for Healthier Children. A Better World. For more information, please visit www.sickkids.ca.
About Lawson Health Research Institute
As the research institute of London Health Sciences Centre and St. Joseph's Health Care London, and working in partnership with Western University, Lawson Health Research Institute is committed to furthering scientific knowledge to advance health care around the world. www.lawsonresearch.com
About Toronto Paramedic Services
Toronto Paramedic Services, is the sole provider of paramedic pre-hospital emergency medical services to over 3 million residents of and visitors to the City of Toronto 365 days a year 24 hours a day 7 days a week. With a staff of 1,300, Toronto's Emergency Medical Dispatchers and Paramedics respond to up to 800 calls to 911 for emergency medical care daily. They are supported by 120 ambulances located in 48 ambulance stations across the City.
The Hospital for Sick Children
416-813-7654, ext. 201436
Lawson Health Research Institute
519-646-6100, ext. 75616
Toronto Paramedic Services